On the Tuesday night season finale of Bachelor In Paradise, the old couples returned to determine who would get the $500,000 cash prize.

And Sean and Allyshia came back with grudges in hand after being eliminated with exuberance by the remaining castmembers.

Sean called for a huddle during the cocktail party to accuse Kat of running behind Dale’s back during the season by sneaking in a laptop and communicating with another man.

This lead to a tearful Kat running away from the party, as the rest of the cast tried to determine what to do with the cash prize.

Viewers had a lot to say about the strategy

Kat basically confirmed what she did was true – the problem is that Sean is the messenger lol #BachelorInParadise

— Brad (@bd199417) September 3, 2025

i also think sean is problematic and always has been. toxic. 🤷🏼‍♀️ #bachelorinparadise pic.twitter.com/jd7LUzZ1Ym

— kami (@kameronmichele) September 3, 2025

Sean has gotten WAY too much airtime in this finale. Especially for a guy who was left the island.. #BachelorInParadise

— Mike (@mike_h1990) September 3, 2025

The way Sean and Allyshia are so fixated on Kat instead of their own relationship is exactly why they aren’t in the final 3 #BachelorInParadise #BIP pic.twitter.com/Mn8GctTKOg

— alexa (@alexaaacameron) September 3, 2025

Sean could’ve went about it differently but Kat didn’t deny anything she just didn’t wanna talk about it on camera… I mean idk #BachelorInParadise pic.twitter.com/z1q80bKmNn

— vanessa (@assenavmarie) September 3, 2025

Sean is fully insane and Allyshia is kind of a c*nt like this is actually scary #BachelorInParadise pic.twitter.com/qxiaKlFiSO

— Lala (@itslalamfz) September 3, 2025

Sean, who do you think you are? Easily the most hated villain of bachelor history lol #BachelorInParadise pic.twitter.com/awOu0PzwBO

— Bre Saunders (@BreeeSaunders) September 3, 2025

Jeremy is so ME when Sean is spilling tea about Kat 💀 #BachelorInParadise pic.twitter.com/JvhGn6oxcP

— Steph R. 🦋🇵🇷 (@stephdizzle11) September 3, 2025

Oh Sean and Allyshia are genuinely really bad people #BachelorInParadise pic.twitter.com/AD2Cx8mqY7

— Angela Murray Stan Account (@pooponnuns) September 3, 2025

I can't stand Sean, but if he has receipts, Kat is just an awful person and got caught, so she's embarrassed. Innocent people dont respond the way she did. #BachelorInParadise pic.twitter.com/LVsfoLdWB2

— randomthoughts (@Shellvi21) September 3, 2025

What do you think? Is Kat guilty? Was Sean wrong to bring it up during the cocktail party? Is it both? Let me know in the comments.

And if you enjoyed this post, please help me see dentist. Learn more HERE. Thank you!